Comments on: Thriller Thursday: Battered Woman Syndrome as Defense for Murder https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363 Twisted Minds and Dark Places Sat, 14 Jul 2012 02:31:06 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.2 By: Stacy Green https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3074 Sat, 14 Jul 2012 02:31:06 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3074 In reply to Sue.

That is just unbelievable. Killed their children too? I can’t even imagine the level of obsession for those men to track the women across states. And I don’t know, but it’s very scary. It’s hard to imagine things getting any better when people are capable of this.

Thanks for stopping by.

]]>
By: Sue https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3073 Sat, 14 Jul 2012 00:18:18 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3073 There were two recent cases in my area whereby battered women did gather the courage to separate themselves from their abusers. The women took legal steps; they did everything right. They filed restraining orders, left the state , changed their names, etc. The husbands tracked them down, killed the women AND their children. How far can we run? How deep can we hide? How long can we protect our children from this type of masculine rage?

]]>
By: Stacy Green https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3072 Thu, 07 Jun 2012 02:32:49 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3072 In reply to lynnkelleyauthor.

Thank you. It was a really tough one to write but I thought it was important. I agree on Judy’s case. She did make the decision, but the punishment should have considered the PTSD. And you’re right – that’s exactly what Battered Women Syndrome is. It’s heartbreaking that it’s still so rampant in this day and age.

Wow, 7 to 10 attempts? That’s awful. But I can understand, in a way. The mind is a fragile, complicated thing, and abuse makes us so vulnerable. As you said, it’s all about manipulation and without a good support system, they don’t have much of a chance.

Thanks so much for the response.

]]>
By: lynnkelleyauthor https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3071 Thu, 07 Jun 2012 02:22:58 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3071 This is an excellent post, Stacy. In Judy’s case, shooting someone while they’re asleep is a bit harder to defend than someone who’s life is in danger at the moment. So I’m not surprised at the outcome, but I believe Battered Woman Syndrome is a form of PTSD, for sure. I’ve known too many women (many very intelligent, beautiful) who have been battered women. It’s a horrible cycle, and the woman wants to believe everything her abuser tells her after the beatings, promising it will never happen again, and blah, blah, blah.

I also learned that it takes an abused woman 7 to 10 attempts at leaving her abuser before she’s finally successful, and that’s only a percentage of them who actually do finally leave the abuser for good. Some never attempt to leave, but for those that do, it seems that once she leaves him, all the horrible memories fall by the way side and she remembers the good times and misses him, doesn’t feel whole without him. If he contacts her during this period, she’s extremely vulnerable to letting him talk her into going back. The abusers use every trick in the book to get her back, and if the woman doesn’t have a good support system, she’s at risk of returning to him. It’s very heart wrenching what these women go through, and I agree with you that no one should ever be subjected to such treatment.

The whole time I was reading your post, I kept thinking of Lorena Bobbitt…

]]>
By: Stacy Green https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3070 Wed, 06 Jun 2012 15:14:39 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3070 In reply to Cayman Thorn.

Absolutely, Cayman. These women are failed constantly. I know people are working hard to pass new laws, but when the abusers are in positions of authority, it’s especially hard to get help. Thanks for stopping by.

]]>
By: Cayman Thorn https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3069 Wed, 06 Jun 2012 14:43:00 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3069 What is not discussed often enough is how the agencies that are supposed to protect these women could not do so. I agree with you. Where do they turn when all else has failed them? When it becomes a matter of their survival, it’s already too late.

]]>
By: Stacy Green https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3068 Wed, 06 Jun 2012 13:52:45 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3068 In reply to susielindau.

Thank you, Suzy. Yes, Delores Claiborne was a tough movie to watch but very good. Glad you enjoyed.

]]>
By: susielindau https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3067 Wed, 06 Jun 2012 13:44:08 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3067 I can’t imagine what it would be like either. I remember the movie “Delores Claiborne,” and how it pulled you inside her abused life. By the end of the movie, it all made sense!
Great review!

]]>
By: Stacy Green https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3066 Wed, 04 Apr 2012 21:47:44 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3066 In reply to hawleywood40.

Thanks, Pam. It was a tough one to do because it’s such a sensitive, important subject. I wouldn’t want to be on one of those juries, either. I understand both women’s plights, and it sucks the law worked against Judy. Thanks so much for your comment!

]]>
By: hawleywood40 https://stacygreenauthor.com/archives/1363#comment-3065 Wed, 04 Apr 2012 19:16:49 +0000 https://stacygreenauthor.com/?p=1363#comment-3065 What a great post, Stacy! As another commenter said, I wouldn’t want to be on one of these juries. I can definitely see how Barbara’s case was more arguably self-defense since her husband was actively threatening her at the time of the murder. But I can also relate to Judy feeling her actions were her only hope of escape if other recourses had failed her. I also think a jury might be more inclined, right or wrong, to understand that desperation in the wife of a police officer. I can’t imagine what it would feel like to know that your abuser was closely affiliated with the people you would be expected to go to for help.

]]>